February 09 2010 09:20:35
Navigation
· Home
· Discussion Forum
· News Categories
· Staff Page
· Search
· RSS Feeds
· Ultimate Stat Page
· Links
· Contact
· Voice Your Opinion
News Feeds




Welcome
Health Care, Insurance and the Middle Class

Advert
Opinions Share
The current health care debate seems to center around those that do not have health insurance. Some of those people don't have it because they are poor, some don't have it because they are young and choose to spend their money or benefits elsewhere and some don't have it because they, for one reason or another, are considered uninsurable. In all of the chatter about health care the Middle Class always seems to get left out of the equation and continues to see their standards of living eroded.

In this piece I'd like to talk about one of the major problems looming on the horizon for these Middle Class Americans that do have health care and what I would propose we do about it to ensure that it remains affordable and that coverage doesn't disappear because they've had a run of bad luck health wise.

This past weekend I was involved in holding a benefit, pancake breakfast to help raise money for a woman who needed surgery for her brain cancer. It was a great event and lots of people came together to show their love and support for the woman and her family. It was the type of event that renews your faith in your fellow human beings and makes you glad to belong to the groups you belong to. That's the great part of this email; the bad part is that the event should have been totally unnecessary.

The reason for this fundraiser was because this family's insurance has an annual expense limit and, because of previous cancer treatments, they had reached their benefit limit for the year.

A couple of weeks ago we learned that a friend's wife was going to have to go in for her third brain cancer surgery as soon as possible. They are hoping to be able to get it all this time and solve the problem. Everything was set and everyone was ready and then the real problem hit. It appears that the family had used up its health insurance benefits for the year and the insurance company would not pay for any of the operation and related costs unless they waited until January to have the procedure done. With brain cancer it is rarely a good option to wait.

These are not people who have shirked their responsibilities. The husband has his own plumbing business and they have purchased their own insurance for the family. However, no one ever expects that they will actually run out of insurance coverage, but this is what happened and as I've researched the subject it appears that this happens more and more these days.

As an example, On Thursday, November 29th, the Wall Street Journal had a page 1 article entitled, "As Medical Costs Soar, The Insured Face a Huge Tab". This article told the story of how a person, who has worked all his life and who carries good medical insurance suddenly found himself facing a huge medical bill and potential financial ruin when his lifetime benefits of $1,500,000 were maxed out due to some severe medical conditions (and what I consider fraudulent hospital billing schemes, but I will deal with that in a later email). In fact, the article goes on to state that the majority of people facing financial problems because of medical bills actually do have health insurance.

This appears to be a problem that should be fairly simple to solve, but since it doesn't involve great sound bites and the ability to be a champion of the poor or illegal, our politicians have no interest in dealing with it.

Shouldn't our political leaders be paying attention to make sure that the 260,000,000 of us who have health insurance and are trying our best to take care of ourselves and our families in a responsible way are given the safety net that appears to be needed in the face of rapidly rising health insurance costs and the potential of catastrophic illness or accident? I say that this is a very important part of the discussion and it is getting lost in the sound bites surrounding the uninsured.

Most of you know that I am not a big proponent of giving the Federal Government more control and involvement in our daily lives, but this may be a case of where Federal Government involvement is necessary.

I believe there should be a Federal safety net for people with insurance who, through no fault of their own, use up their health insurance and are left without coverage when they need it most because of a catastrophic illness or injury. People who try to do the right thing (buy or have a job with insurance coverage) should always have the backing of the government for circumstances far beyond their control.

I believe there should be a Federal health insurance pool for people who cannot buy health insurance from traditional sources similar to the Flood Insurance Program currently in place and the Disaster Insurance Program that I have proposed in an earlier email concerning the government's response to disasters.

The true purpose of a Federal health insurance program should be to prevent people from suffering financial ruin when a major medical event happens in their lives, not to pay for every little thing and every time they want to see the doctor. When a governmental program starts to pay for every little thing, it gets abused, our money is wasted and costs spiral even more out of control.

Let's do what is right by all Americans and develop a safety net so that everyone has the ability to be covered against the major medical events and can buy major medical insurance while maintaining some individual responsibility for the day-to-day health care items whether it is through their one's own private insurance policy, an employer insurance policy or by paying for it out one's own pocket.

The health care system in the United States is a huge part of our economy and will only grow larger as our population continues to age. I will have further emails on this subject as we continue towards the election to discuss other parts of the equation that also appear to be in need of adjustment.
Comments
#1 | rwahrens on December 10 2007 12:40:26
Interesting and thoughtful piece.

However, as one of those very folks you speak of, I am of the opposite opinion. The reason is that I am likely to see my taxes rise, no matter who wins next year.

The Federal Government is asked to pay for more and more every time someone comes up with another demographic group that has some problem. Yes, often these problems are dibilitating and financially ruinous, but we can't, as a country, pay for every catastrophic occurrance to strike an American citizen. (Much less all of the folks here with Green cards... or the illegals, etc.)

There are a lot of things that we have on our plates now, that we haven't even agreed how to solve, so how the heck are we going to find a way to take care of this one? A program like this could cost billions!

And you'll expect the middle class to pay for it, cause there isn't anybody else that can. How'll that work, again?
#2 | seaman93555 on December 10 2007 13:12:48
I could not disagree more rwahrens, since I now find myself without health insurance, since I am disabled. The real crux of the problem is not the insurance crisis, but the cost of health care, which has out-paced inflation in recent years. Solve that problem and we will be on the way to more affordable coverage.
#3 | Redoubt on December 10 2007 13:18:41
The cost of healthcare is directly related to the healthcare insurance industry that feeds from it. Instead of one market sector to support, there's two.
#4 | rwahrens on December 10 2007 13:35:36
Agreed, that if we could find a way to make health care cheaper, we could make the insurance last longer. Perhaps then, many of the problems he cites wouldn't happen... or at least not as often.

My objection isn't the principle involved. Making sure everybody gets health care is the goal, and a worthy one at that.

I just don't think a program like this is affordable. You're asking the very targets of the program to fund it, and such a thing is unsustainable in the long run.
#5 | seaman93555 on December 10 2007 14:01:07
Thanks for your clarification rwahrens, I still believe we need to examine closely and scrutinize carefully the entire health care system, since I know personally of people, who cannot afford their prescription drugs and find themselves having to decide between prescriptions or food and/or energy costs. I believe one of the endemic factors in the health care crisis has to do with the skyrocketing costs in recent years. It seems Americans pay for the research and development cost of new drugs in prescription costs.
#6 | rwahrens on December 10 2007 14:17:01
" It seems Americans pay for the research and development cost of new drugs in prescription costs."

Yes, and it seems that they expect us to be the only ones!
#7 | boomer on December 11 2007 12:00:35
I believe we will evolve into a universal health care system with a mixture of private sector and government programs.
God forbid the government run all of it. That would be like Zimbabwae federalizing all agriculture activities.
#8 | rwahrens on December 11 2007 12:37:01
<shudder>
#9 | boomer on December 11 2007 13:40:15
ditto
#10 | MplsVala on December 14 2007 23:16:20
I'm for universal health care ASAP. We'll fix the bumps as they come along.
Post Comment
Please Login to Post a Comment.
Ratings
Rating is available to Members only.

Please login or register to vote.

No Ratings have been Posted.
Latest Articles
Last 10 Comments
With a Public Platform, Sarah Palin is Moving Secretly Behind Scenes
12283 "The Gravina Island Bridge, commonly referred to as the "Bridge to Nowhere", was a proposed bridge to replace the ferry that currently connects the town of Ketchikan, Alaska with Gravin - seaman93555
With a Public Platform, Sarah Palin is Moving Secretly Behind Scenes
12283 "Supports female equal rights, equal pay, and a number of related issues She has openly and, through her actions, opposed equal rights for gay citizens As those who are regulars on this site kno - seaman93555
Russian passenger jet crashes in Ukraine
15 What is up everyone? My name is Jessica. I am from Slovakia. I am new to the forum and just wanted to say hi.. I hope I posted this in the right section on your forum... [u - juliuspowers
Palin Willing to Run in 2012
12295 [quote]I'm not here to pick fights with people who use mean or offensive language...[/quote] Particularly when you agree with their worldview. Do I owe you a nickle for that shrink session? - JohnWarePT
Palin Willing to Run in 2012
12295 Ah...this is why I try to avoid these spaces. Even in the most professional contexts, this new media feedback section just isn't as productive as it was hyped to be. I'm not here to pick f - mbentel
Palin Willing to Run in 2012
12295 "Loony" and "idiotic" are mild compared to Lionel Rolf's rant referring to Ronald Reagan as a "senile imbecile" and Sarah Palin as a "hate buoy." But I g - JohnWarePT
With a Public Platform, Sarah Palin is Moving Secretly Behind Scenes
12283 Dr. Haines, Your first mistake was making broad statements about Governer Palin's positions without first researching and attributing a reputable source. As a medical intern, I think you know - JohnWarePT
Study Reveals Three Most Important Factors Of Childhood Obesity
12305 Problems with this study: 1. It appears that the scientists first decided what would be the most important factors and set out to "prove" their hypothesis. Such studies are notorious fo - ethwc
With a Public Platform, Sarah Palin is Moving Secretly Behind Scenes
12283 Okay, I promised a better supported statement, here it is. Most of the positions presented here can be found at [u - ethwc
Palin Willing to Run in 2012
12295 @ smithy12: uh...thanks for bringing name calling into this. Your comment after "for your information" would have completely sufficed and been respectable. Instead you had to (incorrectly - mbentel
Most Recent Opinion Pieces
The State of Change
Political Log Jams
Is Obama Going to Force Leftists to the Center?
Women's Role Vastly Changing in 21st Century
Massachusetts and the Democrat Party
Prop8 in trial - Perry v. Schwarzenegger
Torture and John Yoo
Comcast v. FCC: A Look at Net Neutrality
Health care cost 101: Physical therapy
The Trouble with Journalism
In Yemen, the Enemy Is the Narrative
Court Ruling on Taser Use Puts Officers' Lives at Risk
A Brief Analysis of Race in American Popular Culture
Health Care Reform Imperfect, But It's A Start
Habitat for Humanity
Fossil Fuel Versus Alternatives
Copenhagen: The Great Crime Scene
We Can't Always Sing and Dance: In Memory of A Good Friend
The Problem of Evil
Where the Banks Went Wrong: The Depositor
Advertisers
Login
Username

Password



Not a member yet?
Click here to register.

Forgotten your password?
Request a new one here.
Adverts
Top Stories Past 7 Days
With a Public Platform, Sarah Palin is Moving Secretly Behind Scenes 15
Prayer Breakfast a Delicate Situation for Spain's PM 10
Palin Willing to Run in 2012 7
Amazon Accepts Macmillan Price Model 6
Russian passenger jet crashes in Ukraine 5
‘No Child’ Law to Receive Reform Treatment 3
Obama Seeks Spending Freeze with Spiraling Budget 3
New Orleans Elects Landrieu as Mayor 2
Is Obama Going to Force Leftists to the Center? 1
Irish National Liberation Army to Disarm 1